From what I've seen, the hate mostly comes from DOA people themselves because they think Marie, Honoka, and Nico aren't good enough and don't fit DOA's "theme". To everyone else, those three fit DOA like a glove and most people don't care about DOA enough to even start hating those three characters like people here do.People seem to love to hate them yet they are incredibly popular
From experience, I would advise you to not try and understand it. But, I had the exact same questions so I brought it up once and it was quite something. If you're interested this was when I had the same thoughts. Do Tread carefully. I like this quote from another user.There is some crazy dissonance with regards to characters in the DOA community that I have yet to wrap my head around.
Don't stay in echo chambers for too long. And don't think too hard about these things. I like DOA but not enough to blindly join the bandwagon.bLuE HaiREd mARie RoSE. aNiMe iS oUT oF PlACe. eLeCtRIc sUPer SpEEd mARtIAl aRTs wiTH SoMe PeNcAK sILat Is TOo mUCH. sHEs sO uNOriGinAL...
wHEre iS mY OppAI sHRinE MAiDeN nINja wITh FiRE pOWers anD tHe DoMiNatRIx dEMon HuNTer WiTh tHE badASS feME fATalE tRoPE
This whole game is tropes With the exception of Leon every single one of your mains is a trope.
Well, that's because you're in a forum with a rather small population. It might become a echo chamber."Everyone" hates copy-pasted DOA 5 characters yet this forum is full of requests for Leon, Gen-Fu and Ein and it was just as bad with Momiji and Rachel prior to their announcements.
If you enjoy the game then that is great. Keep on playing.I guess that's the advantage of this being my first DOA: I can accept it for what it is and, while I do look forward to improvements, I am having a lot of fun with it. I was so curious about DOA 5 and the praise it gets compared to 6 that I decided to buy it. I guess my expectations were set too high but outside of some interesting levels, I was underwhelmed and would rather continue playing 6.
From what I've seen, the hate mostly comes from DOA people themselves because they think Marie, Honoka, and Nico aren't good enough and don't fit DOA's "theme". To everyone else, those three fit DOA like a glove and most people don't care about DOA enough to even start hating those three characters like people here do.
And that's the point of guest characters: to get non-fans potentially invested in the game.
Yeah, I understand your POV that they came out of nowhere but the public and players made them popular. Just compare Marie and Honoka to Rig and Mila. One pair still lives and the other is already forgotten by the majority. It's not the people's fault TN can't make their "Itagaki era" characters interesting.I think the hate for Marie and Honoka runs a bit deeper than that. Gotta look at it like this, to long time DOA fans they really just came out of nowhere with no real place in the lore and quickly took over the franchise. I kinda view Marie specifically as a turn in the series since it started the trend of new girls we see today. You really have to put yourself in that scenario where some random loli characters managed to take over a series people mostly associate with ninjas and busty, stylized women from the Itagaki era. They appeared in Warriors All Stars and Xtreme 3 over long time veterans like Tina and Christie which angered a lot of people. It's less the fault of the characters and more the fault of just how popular they are.
I see it like this. The Itagaki era failed to get people to care about DOA (DOA1-4, Mila, and Rig) so TN is "entering a new era" because of the success of Marie and Honoka. Either stick with the same old formula and gain nothing or stick to the new thing that got popular and see where it goes. It's just that the new girls don't fit the fetishes and tropes DOA people are accustomed to so they bash them. All you need to do is step back and look at all the characters objectively. The new girls are no different from the old girls. Maybe DOA people bash on them as an excuse as to why the game is doing poorly? I don't know and it doesn't really matter anymore. Things are already set.Ultimately idk the exact reasons why people here hate them but they undoubtedly changed the direction of DOA so that's enough reason to understand. I personally don't get the appeal, but I can accept them as part of the roster. There's more to be mad at with DOA6 really
Yeah, I've always looked at it from the perspective of balance of influences. You can see from the start of the series that there were a number of influences in character design, even from real-life people (e.g. Dennis Rodman, Hulk Hogan, etc.). But, then you bring in something like Marie, Honoka, or NiCO, and it seems like they're only copying from other outlandish anime characters that were themselves copied from other anime characters that were only based on kind of an "idea" of some kind of fetish, e.g., "goth loli".I think the hate for Marie and Honoka runs a bit deeper than that. Gotta look at it like this, to long time DOA fans they really just came out of nowhere with no real place in the lore and quickly took over the franchise. I kinda view Marie specifically as a turn in the series since it started the trend of new girls we see today. You really have to put yourself in that scenario where some random loli characters managed to take over a series people mostly associate with ninjas and busty, stylized women from the Itagaki era. They appeared in Warriors All Stars and Xtreme 3 over long time veterans like Tina and Christie which angered a lot of people. It's less the fault of the characters and more the fault of just how popular they are.
Admittedly my biggest gripe with Marie at first was how out of place she looked in the game, she just looked so... anime? DOA always had this blend of Japanese and Western style with character design for me and she seemed so generic and from another series completely. Like if you showed me a pic of Marie at the time before she was in the game and asked me what series she was from, I would have never guessed DOA. Same with Honoka, just looked like another school girl from some random anime. So you're right about the dissonance as I couldn't see how they fit DOA as a glove at all like everyone else. As you pointed out though it's pretty silly to think this given all the characters are pretty much anime and filled with by the numbers tropes so it doesn't bother me anymore. Honoka I hate mostly just for being "boobs the character" despite having to be a main character. Nico is cool just hate fighting the bitch.
Ultimately idk the exact reasons why people here hate them but they undoubtedly changed the direction of DOA so that's enough reason to understand. I personally don't get the appeal, but I can accept them as part of the roster. There's more to be mad at with DOA6 really
You seem to be under the impression that DOA is more popular now than it was before when that's not really the case overall.I see it like this. The Itagaki era failed to get people to care about DOA (DOA1-4, Mila, and Rig) so TN is "entering a new era" because of the success of Marie and Honoka. Either stick with the same old formula and gain nothing or stick to the new thing that got popular and see where it goes
I see it like this. The Itagaki era failed to get people to care about DOA (DOA1-4, Mila, and Rig) so TN is "entering a new era" because of the success of Marie and Honoka. Either stick with the same old formula and gain nothing or stick to the new thing that got popular and see where it goes. It's just that the new girls don't fit the fetishes and tropes DOA people are accustomed to so they bash them. All you need to do is step back and look at all the characters objectively. The new girls are no different from the old girls. Maybe DOA people bash on them as an excuse as to why the game is doing poorly? I don't know and it doesn't really matter anymore. Things are already set.
Nope, I'm not. There's a reason I mentioned the "success of Marie and Honoka" in this conversation about characters.You seem to be under the impression that DOA is more popular now than it was before when that's not really the case overall.
If that's true then I take back what I said. But, from how people talk about the series I find it hard to believe it was that popular in the 2-4 era.I don't think this is true, DOA was more popular back in DOA 2-4 era than right now, that is why they need a gacha game full of "waifus".
You can build your characters from tropes and still make them interesting and loved. As I said, Rachel Alucard and Amy Sorel are also gothic lolitas but unlike Marie Rose they have a lot more care and thought put in them. Marie Rose concept (Wicked Lil' Servant) was interesting but they didn't care to develop her, her design was enough to print money.
I'm honestly still just salty that we could've had any KOF fighter alongside Mai and we got Kula lol
(...) If they wanted to be accurate to the game they’d have to make them obsessed with him to a degree that makes Leifang’s stalking seem positively well-adjusted