Oh no no, one thing is that I think their designs are uninspired (Honoka and NiCO the most imo since they’re just too close to Honoka from Love Live—thing that probably explains why our Honoka is so popular since Love Live is so big there atm—, and the Ram or Rem girl from that anime idc about) and another thing is that I hate them, thing that I don’t. In fact, I actually like Marie Rose and her design even if she’s your usual loli type character design plus she has some nice costumes, and I’m actually waiting to see what NiCO is capable of in terms of gameplay and character development and costume design. Honoka tho... meh. I don’t like her, but not hate her either. I just don’t care about her.
I’m sorry if I sounded too hard on them, I just love Mila and Nyo’s designs more than theirs and I may have slipped a bit and ended throwing too much shade to the poor girls lol
Pretty sure our Honoka is popular because of all the tits and body fat - which LL's Honoka and the entire DOA cast don't have as much of. Though some people stuck around for the salad moveset too
NiCO is a "cool character with cool-colored hair" trope first and foremost (not the series' first when you think about it), I'm not a huge fan of Rem nor that sloppy hairstyle, but the hair is probably a convenient coincidence as they wanted to show off their punch-head-accessories-off mechanics
I actually like Marie as much as I do Lisa, as they both stand out (if you cropped off the cast's heads I'd have a bad time distinguishing anything other than these), have damn fluid animations and physics, and fun personalities.
The design is very common, but frilly goth girls are often totally 3000 years old [supernatural being]s, so a regular human bean that doesn't go "ara sweaty did you really think i was a little girl" is a bit convention-defying in itself
I think you definitely got consumed by bias, though. Most character designs in this series already play by the textbook. The dark-haired Chinese character is obsessed with martial arts, the character with short hot-colored hair is a tomboy, the traditional Japanese hime cut girl in a Japanese dress combo, the rich ojou is of course blonde and drips with pomposity, the femme fatale assassin, every kunoichi of course has gigantic knockers, the big bad is naked, and so on. I can find the same tropes all over anime, fighters or just fiction in general and the only ones I would probably have trouble with are the La Mariposa persona and Brad Wong
But I'll quote DOAN, tropes and "usual character designs" aren't inherently bad. Lazy on the creator's end, but easy to digest on the consumer's end. The Tekken community still manages to have a shitstorm every time it does something unusual. Too tried and true is anime, too special snowflake is apparently ALSO anime. Make up your minds, otherwise this will just be another catch all term for [thing I don't like].
But visual design is ultimately superficial. In this genre if a character is above spouting things like prepare yourself, I'm ready, I'll do my best, that's my [fighting style], nothing personnel kid, they're already a step ahead on the inspiration ladder. I swear to god at least half of the rosters of every fighting game does this regardless of what they look like